Skip to main content

The Hidden Math on Rural Physician Vacancies

November 18, 2026

Every November, National Rural Health Day recognizes the people who deliver care in rural communities across the country. As Regional Vice President for the Western division at Jackson Physician Search, I work with leaders of hospitals, clinics, and medical groups across some of the most rural and remote parts of the country, and the recognition is well earned. These organizations sustain essential services with razor-thin margins, stretching resources farther than one might imagine possible.

That resourcefulness has a blind spot, though, and a new report from Jackson Physician Search, LocumTenens.com and the Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) puts a number on it. Rural leaders track nearly every expense in the building. However, one of the most consequential costs is one that most haven’t calculated — the cost of a physician vacancy.

The Number Most Organizations Don’t Have

The aforementioned report, Rural Healthcare Specialty Priorities, documents the results of a survey of 227 rural administrators and clinicians. In it, administrators described their single most consequential physician vacancy of the past three years. Only 25% formally estimated its financial effect, and just 14% factored in downstream effects such as referrals, imaging, and admissions. Most often (43%), organizations made no estimate or evaluation at all.

That blind spot matters because rural physician vacancies are rarely a quick fix. Sixty-five percent were still active searches at the time of the survey, and more than four in ten searches had already run seven months or longer. A cost that compounds for seven months is not a rounding error. It accounts for a significant loss of revenue, and most leaders are carrying it without a figure attached.

The absence of a number also makes it hard to make a case for the cost of a solution. When a CFO asks whether it’s worth investing in a recruitment partner and/or paying for interim coverage, “We’re losing money” is not an answer. A specific monthly figure is.

How to Build the Estimate

The full report includes a worksheet, Price Your Own Vacancy, designed to help you quickly produce a rough monthly estimate for a single position. It’s deliberately simple. Use internal figures where you have them, and benchmarks where you don’t.

You’ll need to identify six numbers:

Direct net revenue the position would generate. Monthly net patient revenue per physician FTE, drawn from your cost report or productivity data. MGMA benchmarks can stand in where internal numbers aren’t available.

Downstream revenue tied to the position. Monthly revenue from referrals, imaging, lab, procedural and surgical volume, and admissions attributable to the specialty. This is the piece most estimates leave out, and in some specialties it’s larger than the direct revenue.

Revenue retained by interim coverage. The share of the first two that your bridge actually preserves. Enter zero if there is no interim approach.

Cost of interim coverage. Locum tenens fees and travel, overtime, extra call and premium pay, contracted telehealth or visiting specialist arrangements.

Recruiting and onboarding cost, spread across the search. Signing bonus, relocation, ramp-up and search costs, divided by the expected months to fill.

Months the position is, or will be, open. Your own recent search history is the best guide here.

From those, the worksheet produces a monthly exposure figure, a total across the expected length of the vacancy, and a third number worth sitting with: what six months of earlier recruiting would have been worth. Our Physician Recruitment ROI Calculator offers a faster starting point if you want a rough figure by specialty before working through the details.

None of this is precision accounting. It’s a planning estimate and a strong starting point.

What the Number Tells You About Timing

Once you have a monthly figure, two decisions get easier. The first is urgency.

The survey found that rural organizations are rarely ahead of their vacancies. Only 12% of these consequential vacancies were anticipated more than a year in advance, and 57% were anticipated less than six months out or not at all. Meanwhile, 64% of administrators expect at least one physician to retire or reduce hours within five years, and only 41% of them have a formal succession plan for any of those departures.

A monthly exposure figure converts that visibility into a decision. If you know a retirement is coming in 18 months and you know what each month of vacancy costs, the case for starting the search now makes itself. If a search is already open and running long, the number reveals how much is at stake and helps you make the case for accelerating it.

What the Number Tells You About Coverage

The second decision is what holds the service together while the search runs. Here the survey found a telling pattern: only 19% of these vacancies had a contingency plan in place before the gap opened. Without one, coverage tends to default to whoever is already in the building, which puts your current staff at risk of burnout. Although respondents rated locum tenens the strongest short-term option of any coverage model (47%), they reported using it in just 12% of cases. More often, organizations turned to physician-and-APP models (21%) or internal physician cross-coverage (18%) to bridge the gap. 

Administrators’ own ratings of their interim arrangements show why the financial estimate belongs in this decision. More than half rated their interim coverage good or excellent for maintaining patient access (52%) and clinical continuity (56%). Only 19% rated it that well for financial sustainability beyond 12 months. The bridge holds care. It doesn’t hold the budget indefinitely.

That’s the practical case for pairing the number with the plan. The estimate tells you how much you can spend to cover the vacancy short-term and fill it permanently (which is still the preferred solution in every specialty, according to the survey). In many cases, greater investment upfront can shorten the vacancy and ultimately save money long-term. 

A Number Worth Having

Rural organizations have always done more with less, and Rural Health Day is a good moment to acknowledge that. But resourcefulness works better with information behind it. A little time spent crunching the numbers provides a figure you can bring to a board meeting, a budget conversation, or a succession discussion. Knowledge is power, and when you know what a vacancy costs, decisions about how to fill it become much clearer. 

Read the full report: Rural Healthcare Specialty Priorities

Jackson Physician Search partners with rural organizations on permanent physician recruitment, from the first expected retirement through placement. If you’d like help putting a number on a vacancy and building a plan around it, our team would be glad to talk. Reach out today.


About Jeff Foster

With more than 15 years of experience in healthcare strategy and physician recruitment, Jeff Foster has partnered with hospitals, health systems, and academic centers across the country to strengthen their recruitment programs and improve processes.

A West Virginia native, Jeff began his career at Charleston Area Medical Center, where he specialized in candidate acquisition, practice start-up, and service line expansion. He later joined National Jewish Health, the nation’s #1 respiratory hospital, to help develop a strategic faculty recruitment office.

In 2016, Jeff joined Jackson Physician Search as one of the first team members in its Denver office. Since then, he has built a reputation as a leading expert in physician recruitment — earning Consultant of the Year multiple times and advancing to his current role as Regional Vice President of Recruiting. In this role, he not only works directly with hospitals to secure top talent but also mentors a growing team of recruiters, helping them achieve long-term career success.

What Jeff values most is seeing people thrive — whether it’s physicians finding their dream jobs, healthcare organizations strengthening their teams, or colleagues achieving new milestones in their careers.

Outside of work, Jeff enjoys skiing, playing soccer, and exploring the outdoors with his wife in Denver.

partner icon

Partner With Jackson Physician Search

Recruiting physicians, physician executives, and advanced practice providers requires a partner with a proven track record of delivering on the toughest recruiting challenges. Since 1978, our team has delivered for thousands of clients nationwide, filling their searches quickly and cost-effectively from our extensive network.

Initiate a Search